Your MOM is complete with Opportunity. Means and Motive account for little if a suspect
doesn’t have the opportunity to
commit and potentially get away with the crime. I must not have a clear understanding myself of MOM because
to me, opportunity is an aspect of
means. But, to others, I guess means
is limited to weapon and ability to use the weapon. How limited is THAT??? Means, to me, clearly implies access,
but, oh, well.
Opportunity, to
the rest of the world, indicates you have to have the potential to be in the crime
area at the right time without an alibi. So if you don’t have a driver’s
license or car, do you have the opportunity
to arrive at the site of the crime? Is there no independent way of accounting
for your time so you had the opportunity
to be there in that time window?
Sometimes opportunity
is serendipitous other times planned. When opportunity
is planned, killing can move over from manslaughter to murder. Remember the
importance of intent in bringing
charges.
Of course, that’s why it’s MOM. All three--means, opportunity, motive--have to be in confluence to make one a viable suspect. And
the detective’s job is to ensure those three solidly nail one suspect. That is maybe the major way author's complicate their mystery plots. Creating anomalies or inconsistencies in MOM causes a likely suspect to be dismissed early on. It's only when there is resolution of MOM that the murderer is revealed.
Mort reveals more of his gift in “The
List”.
Obediently, he
rose to do her bidding. As Mort
clomped his flat-footed way down the front steps of the deck to the beach road,
Fran sipped her wine and lit the last of the cigarettes in her pack. She drew
the acrid air deep into her lungs and held it there, finally expelling a long,
thin stream of smoke into the approaching dusk. Mort returned to find her
contemplating the second key.
“And
this one, Darling? What in the world is this key to?”
“That,
Frieda, is the key to a co-op on the upper East Side. It’s small, just two
bedrooms, but it’s right where the action is and around the corner from Le Pain
Quotidien so you can eat there more often. It has a view of the Park. It also
has a parking garage, and you know how hard those are to find in the City.”
Mort smiled, seeming satisfied with himself and all the arrangements he had
completed.
Hi - an interesting take on the sameness of means and opportunity. Although - a small plot developed in my head - if you're in a nursing home, and you are being mistreated, you have opportunity because you're around your caregivers everyday, but don't have the means unless you find a creative way to run them over with your wheelchair. :)
ReplyDeleteYeah, I know what you're saying. It's just that they are so closely tied. But then so is motive. I guess that's the importance of MOM--all together the case comes together. Again, thanks for being such a loyal reader here. Much appreciated. I saw that you saw the tweets I sent out about your blog. I hope others found you that way.
DeleteGreat tips for crime writers, and interesting choice of theme. Appreciate the amount of work involved.
ReplyDeleteHere from the A-Z, and best of luck for the rest of the challenge.
Nilanjana
Thanks, Nilanjana. It's been a fun month to do! Thanks so much for stopping by to read and comment. The challenge is a great way to meet new bloggers.
Delete